Quiz

Can We Ever Truly Innovate?

Can We Ever Truly Innovate?

Every generation believes it is creating something that was never done before, but at least with art we always go back into the junk drawer of history to find the tools we need to move forward. Will AI change that?

People often say they don’t “get” modern art, but if you look at it closely, you’ll see that a lot of it hasn’t changed at all for thousands of years. While some of the art from the last century or so may feel like a radical break from tradition, it was actually a homecoming. In the world of culture, the path to the future often runs through the deep past.

In the early 1900s, artists felt suffocated by the rigid, hyper-realistic standards of the time. To break free, they didn’t look for something “new”; they looked for something “old”. Very old. They became obsessed with some of humanity’s earliest artistic attempts, such as the minimalist marble figurines of the Bronze Age Cycladic culture in Greece from the 4th and 3rd millennium BCE. By adopting these sharp lines and abstract shapes, the modernists were reconnecting with a primal artistic language that had been dormant for millennia, thereby sparking a revolution in the arts. Such is the sculpture ‘Head’ (1911–1912) by the Italian artist Amedeo Modigliani, inspired by Cycladic art as well as African art.

This cycle is the engine of human culture. Every generation believes it is standing on a precipice of total novelty, yet we inevitably reach back into the junk drawer of history to find the tools we need to move forward and innovate. The Renaissance (15th-16th century) obsessed over Classical Greece; the Romantics (19th century) yearned for the Middle Ages; Hip Hop looked back to Jazz, Soul and Funk, and Jazz pioneers could have never invented their own revolution without going back to African rhythm. We are a species that moves forward by looking over our shoulder.

Now, we face a new frontier with Artificial Intelligence. As algorithms begin to churn out “original” art and literature, some fear that the human chain of continuity has finally been broken. But even AI is a retrospective ‘artist’. It creates by scouring the entirety of our collective history – from cave paintings to digital art, from ancient poetry to spoken word – and remixing it. In art as in life, there is nothing new under the sun; there is only the eternal, human habit of remembering.

Group Activity

  1. Divide the group into several teams.
  2. Pick one of the questions from the list below and let each team discuss it and then present their thoughts to the group; Alternatively, assign each team with a different question, and when they present it to the group ask the remaining teams for their thoughts as well.

Questions

    1. Were you surprised by which sculptures were prehistoric and which were modern? What assumptions did you make, and why?
    2. The text mentions the Renaissance borrowing from Greece, Hip Hop from Jazz, Romantics from the Middle Ages. Can you think of other examples from music, fashion, film, or your own cultural world where the “new” was actually a return to something older?
    3. The text argues that AI creates by scanning everything humans have ever made. Does that make AI creativity more like human creativity than we assume, or is there still a meaningful difference? What would that difference be?
    4. If AI creates a painting by remixing millions of human works, who made it? The engineers? The users? The dead artists whose work trained the model?
    5. If art always moves forward by looking backward, and AI now holds the entire archive of human history, what do you think art will look like 100 years from now?

Discover more...

What’s So Special About AI?

We call it “artificial intelligence”. But AI doesn’t think the way you do, or at all. So what is it?

Is Race a Real Thing?

Many think of race as if it’s part of human biology, but the idea’s history is complicated

Are Fish Conscious? And AI?

The science of animal consciousness is rewriting what we thought we knew

Unstoppable Us: The Detective Game

A new educational workshop in the format of a detective game. Get it now!